Would Making Ransom Payments Illegal Result in Fewer Attacks?

Would Making Ransom Payments Illegal Result in Fewer Attacks?

July 31, 2024 at 10:09AM

According to Netwrix’s “2024 Hybrid Security Trends Report,” ransomware and other malware attacks are major security incidents. There’s debate about making ransomware payments illegal. While banning payments might eliminate cybercriminals’ incentive, it could lead to complex ethical and legal issues, including underreporting and disproportionate impact on small businesses. A multifaceted approach is proposed instead, including government cybersecurity benchmarks and law enforcement collaboration.

Based on the meeting notes, here are the key takeaways:

1. Ransomware and other malware attacks are a major concern for organizations, and there is ongoing discussion about making ransomware payments illegal to curb such attacks. However, there are ethical, legal, and practical complexities to consider.

2. Prohibiting ransom payments may not be effective as it could lead to unreported incidents, particularly impacting small and medium-sized businesses, and resulting in unintended consequences.

3. The role of cyber insurance in facilitating ransomware payments and potential contributions to the growth of ransomware attacks should be carefully considered.

4. A multifaceted approach, similar to the banking industry’s strategy for reducing bank robberies, could be effective in combating ransomware. This includes establishing cybersecurity benchmarks, enhancing security measures, and increasing international collaboration among law enforcement agencies.

5. The comprehensive and nuanced approach to addressing ransomware involves organizations taking greater responsibility for cybersecurity and government agencies engaging in effective law enforcement efforts.

These takeaways emphasize the need for a balanced and holistic approach to addressing ransomware attacks, considering the complexities and potential unintended consequences associated with a blanket ban on ransom payments.

Full Article