When Good Security Awareness Programs Go Wrong

When Good Security Awareness Programs Go Wrong

November 9, 2023 at 02:13PM

An email sent by a company informing employees about a holiday bonus turned out to be a phishing simulation. Employees were required to fill out a form with personal details to claim the bonus, failing the test instead. Instead of receiving the bonus, they were mandated to take security awareness training. This approach eroded trust among employees and hindered behavior change. A compliance-driven approach to security awareness training that focuses on completion rates rather than meaningful behavior change is ineffective. Phishing simulations should prioritize education over tricking employees, as focusing on “gotcha” moments can create a culture of distrust and anxiety. Security awareness programs should be flexible and adaptable to an evolving threat landscape. The ultimate goal is to cultivate a security culture where employees promptly report suspicious activities.

In summary, the meeting notes discussed the importance of effective security awareness training programs for employees. It highlighted that using tactics such as phishing simulations without empathy can erode trust among employees and hinder the objectives of the program. Instead, the focus should be on empowering employees and creating a safe environment in which they can approach the security team if they spot something suspicious. The compliance-driven approach of treating awareness training as a checkbox exercise was deemed ineffective, and it was recommended to take a strategic approach that includes audience analysis and segmentation for targeted training. The notes also emphasized the need for flexibility and adaptability in security awareness programs due to the evolving threat landscape. The ultimate goal is to cultivate a security culture where employees promptly report unusual activities or mistakes as a sign that the security program is effective.

Full Article